logo

Home
About
Events
World Sankirtan Party
Inside Nam Hatta
KRSNA WORLD Blog
Archive
eBooks
View Site Map
Contact
Store
Srila Prabhupada[Posted March 7, 2008]

Scientists in Need of a Discovery



A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

Changing ideas and theories with the wind's direction

RADHAVALLABHA: One professor was telling me that he didn't think you should write about all these things about the universe in your books, because none of the scientists will believe it. So I told him that all the scientists were hogs, dogs, camels and asses, and he became enraged, and he left.


Comment

Send this story to a friend

Printer Friendly Page











The Bhaktivedantas World Sankirtan Party and Inside Nam Hatta are hosted by Hansadutta das, a senior disciple of Srila Prabhupada and trustee of The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust. Participate or learn more about World Sankirtan Party.
Science and Spirituality
Real Scientist Means... A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
PRABHUPADA: Yes. They are misleading. They have no knowledge, and they are misleading. The basic principle of knowledge... They have no idea of spiritual basic principle. They take material basic principle. Therefore the beginning of their knowledge is wrong.

ROBERT GOUIRAN: Yes, yes, yes.

PRABHUPADA: So on the wrong platform you may go, go forward more and more, but it will be dismantled because it is wrong. more

Claiming to be scientists and bluffing people


excerpt from conversation with disciples, Honolulu, May 12, 1976

PUSTA KRSNA: But it's not so unbelievable.

PRABHUPADA: And what is, the scientists will not believe? We say, tatha dehantara-praptih: [Bhagavad-gita 2.13] "As the child is becoming boy, boy is becoming, similarly you have to change body." What scientist has to challenge this? But they are obstinate dog. Dehantara-praptih you have to accept. Can the scientist say, "No, no, no, the child is not going to be a young man or boy"? Can he say like that? Then why they challenge unnecessarily? They are changing the body. Can the scientists stop it? But if they are unreasonable dogs, then what can be done? What argument will reach them? A dog cannot understand.

RADHAVALLABHA: Just stick.

PRABHUPADA: Yes. No, they will not understand even with stick. You see? They are less than dog. Bhagavad-gita says, dehino 'smin yatha dehe kaumaram yauvanam jara [Bg. 2.13], very simple argument, that "As the child is becoming boy, boy is becoming young man, young man is becoming middle-aged man, and middle-aged is becoming old man, similarly, you are changing body." So where is the difficulty to understand? But they are so obstinate rascal, they will not believe. As soon as the child is dead, does he become boy?

PUSTA KRSNA: No.

PRABHUPADA: So what is that? What is the scientists' reply?

RADHAVALLABHA: They say he's dead.

PRABHUPADA: So why dead?

RADHAVALLABHA: They say the brain and the heart stopped working.

PRABHUPADA: So you replace it, rascal.

RADHAVALLABHA: We're working on it.

PRABHUPADA: Obstinate dogs. They are mudhas [fools], and they will continue to remain mudha. Then how you can make him enlightened? They cannot answer properly. Why a dead child born does not grow, does not change body? The body is a lump of matter. Analyze the body. Where is life? These are all very reasonable. But they will not. Dog's obstinacy. How you can convince them? Simply waste of time, talk with them. Therefore they should be neglected.

RADHAVALLABHA: They did one experiment where they took a...

PRABHUPADA: Eh?

RADHAVALLABHA: They did an experiment where they took an embryo of a child, and they put it in a test tube, large bottle, and they were growing it by feeding it, and it just turned into a shapeless blob.

PRABHUPADA: So why did you take embryo from the child? You make embryo. You cannot make even an egg which can be..., give a chicken. So to waste time with these rascals is very difficult.

No, it is useless to talk with them. If you can peacefully sell some books, that's all. Don't enter into very long arguments, because they are all rascals. They cannot understand. Better peacefully, as far as possible, sell some books.

This is the process. They cannot understand that because there is soul within the child, therefore child is becoming boy. As soon as there is no soul, the child does not become a boy. This simple philosophy they cannot understand, so what is their position? Now, this car is standing because there is no driver. Anyone can understand. Stand still. It will remain there for thousands of years unless a driver comes. Simple reason. But they are so rascal, they will not understand. So what is the use of talking with them? Simply waste of time.

DEVOTEE (1): These people cannot be converted.

PRABHUPADA: That is a fact. The dog cannot be converted. But we have to do it with stick. [break] ...that a dead child can be brought scientifically into life and he will grow, and still, they'll argue. So what is the use of argument with these rascals? When they are caught up, that "Do this," "Yes, we shall do in the future," and "What about the present?" there is no answer.

HARI-SAURI: Everywhere we see millions and millions of different types of bodies are all growing, there's living force there, but still, they haven't been able to find it, and it's there all the time, everywhere, surrounding them, so what kind of scientists?

PRABHUPADA: [The scientists speak of] improvement. Have you improved this, that a dead body can be brought into life by scientific arrangement? And still, they'll say "improvement." What improvement? Simply dry talks, that is science?

First subject matter for scientific advancement, that there is soul within the body. On account of the presence of the soul, the body is changing. So the soul is different from the body. So this is the first education of scientist. And they have avoided this major.... They simply bluffing people, "We have discovered this..." What you have discovered? Discover this: What is the principle within the body? Real discovery, they are not interested. They are bluffing. They are fools, making others fools and going on as scientific advancement. First of all answer this.

Can you challenge? "Do this first. What is your science? This is rascal science. You give up the major problem; you are making research how many atoms are working. What you will do by understanding atoms are going?"

PUSTA KRSNA: Because it's very difficult to...

PRABHUPADA: Difficult? Then you are not scientist. You cannot touch the difficult problem. Childish thing, you are bluffing children, that's all. You have no power to tackle the difficulties. You cannot give life to the dead body.

HARI-SAURI: But if we don't make the research, then how will we ever solve these problems?

PRABHUPADA: Then you are.... As soon as you say "making research," then you are not perfect. Don't say that you are scientist. You are student. Don't say that you are scientist. And you are declaring, "There is no authority, nothing." Why do you speak all this nonsense? Because you are not scientist. You are making research. That's all right. When you complete your research—you come to the conclusion—then call yourself as scientist. Why, as a student, neophyte, you are claiming as "scientist"? Why misleading people? You do not know anything, how things are going on, and you are claiming you are scientist. Our point is, "Don't do this, misleading propaganda. You are not scientist. We protest against this false propaganda. Why you are making.... You do not know anything. You cannot solve any problem, major problem, so why you are claiming scientist? Stop this as a gentleman."

And there is the soul within the body, and when the soul is gone, transferred to another body, it is dead. Dhiras tatra na muhyati [Bg. 2.13]. One who is actually scientist, he is not surprised. He knows the soul has transferred to another body. That's all. That is scientist. He is real scientist, not a rascal like you. We don't give.... You cannot act. We accept Krishna as scientist because He explains. You cannot explain. How we can accept you as scientist? You are rascal. Up till now, nobody was able to explain—simply vague. How we can accept these vague explanation as scientist? And daily changing, every year new theories. And I have to accept you scientist? Krishna said tatha dehantara-praptih [Bg. 2.13: "As the embodied soul continuously passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. A sober person is not bewildered by such a change."] five thousand years ago. It was known very well, and it is going on. That is science. You cannot give any solution, you are changing your ideas and theories every year, and we have to accept you as scientist? Madman, crazy fellow, saying something today, saying something other next day.


Back to Top
Sri Guru and Gauranga
Sri Guru and Gauranga

Related Articles

The Founder Acharya
The Challenge
Life Comes From Life
Getting Two Plus Two Wrong
Make Up Your Minds
Posing as Scientists
Science Based on "Perhaps, Maybe"
"In Future We Shall Do It"
Real Scientist Means...




Related Topics


Science

Life Comes From Life